1. This is a really lame list because it doesn't include Janis Ian's "At Seventeen"

elinqoe at 8:13PM on May 5th 2007

2. Honey _bobby Goldsboro??
Wildfire?
Have you seen Her?

Adrob at 8:14PM on May 5th 2007

3. Astonishing. How could you even NOT consider "Goodbye to Love" by the Carpenters? That blows my mind. It is one of the saddest songs of all time!

"Time and time again the chance for love has passed me by and all I know of love is how to live without it - I just can't seem to find it."

Those aren't sad words? Sheesh, gimme a break.

Rob at 8:14PM on May 5th 2007

4. What about "last kiss" by Pearl Jam?

drew at 8:14PM on May 5th 2007

5. Tears from Heaven by Eric Clapton. How could any song be sadder than the one he wrote for his late 5 year old son, who died falling from a hotel window. I cry every time I hear it.

Claudia Wolf at 8:15PM on May 5th 2007

6. The list should've included "Last Kiss" covered by Pearl Jam.

Jolene Richardson at 8:16PM on May 5th 2007

7. what about gravedigger by dave matthews band?

marissa at 8:17PM on May 5th 2007

8. I have two songs that I could have seen in there.

Dixie Chicks - Traveling Soldiers
About a girl's young love and his death far away.

Alabama - In Pictures
About a man who never gets to see his daughter grow up in person, only through pictures.

Jorge at 8:18PM on May 5th 2007

9. Uhh.... how can you not include one of the most recorded saddest songs of all time??? "All By Myself" by Eric Carmen! The title says it all, you don't even have to SEARCH the lyrics to know it. LAME list.

Paul at 8:18PM on May 5th 2007

10. Can't believe you didn't consider "Alone Again, Naturally" by Gilbert O'Sullivan or "Where've You Been" by Kathy Mattea

Pete at 8:18PM on May 5th 2007

11. Tears from Heaven by Eric Clapton. How could any song be sadder than one written inspired by the death of his 5 year old son, who died falling from a hotel window. I cry every time I hear it. Heartbreaking tenderness and vulnerability.

Claudia Wolf at 8:19PM on May 5th 2007

12. You Need to Ad george jones (the grand tour) one of the best tear jerkers ever

kdog at 8:19PM on May 5th 2007

13. what about metallca's fade to black? its about wanting to commit suicide because of lifes changes.thats sader than the beegees

josh at 8:19PM on May 5th 2007

14. Keep Me In Your Heart For A While by Warren Zevon?? " Shadows are falling and I'm running out of breath; keep me in your heart for a while". One of the last songs he wrote before he died. This should be on the list.

Jason at 8:20PM on May 5th 2007

15. My Immortal by Evanescence???? totally sad! Longing
for a lost love one, describing the emotions and the
pain... sadness...

Jim at 8:20PM on May 5th 2007