• AOL
  • MAIL
    • You might also like: 
    • Music | 
    • Movies | 
    • TV | 
    • Celebrity News
    •  and More
    Sign In / Register
Spinner
  • Main
  • Spinner RPM
  • Features
    • The Hit List
    • Spinner Interview
    • Music Appreciation
  • Songs
    • Free MP3 of the Day
    • Play Full Albums Free
  • Videos
    • The Interface
    • Sessions
    • Video of the Day
    • All Videos
  • Radio
    • AOL Radio
    • AOL Radio Toolbar
    • Shoutcast
  • AOL Music Sites
    • The Boot
    • The BoomBox
    • Noisecreep
    • AOL Music Blog
  • SXSW
  • Signature Sounds
    • This Week's Feature:

    • Get a taste of Atlanta via hometown heroes Big Boi, David Banner, Q Parker and more.
  • Send Feedback
  • Blake Shelton

    Are Blake and Miranda Lambert Ready for Kids?
  • Rob Gibb Dead

    Bee Gee Loses Battle With Cancer
  • Jennifer Lopez

    J.Lo Makes Shocking Statement About 'Idol'
  • Marilyn Manson

    Can You Tell Who This Teen Grew Up to Be?

Spinner Exclusives

  • The Interface - Live Performances
  • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free
  • Spinner Radio
  • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free

Features

  • Best Songs 2011
  • Top Albums of 2011
  • Sad Songs
  • Music Geeks in Film
  • Best Opening Lyrics

All Categories

  • After Hours(4)
  • Call and Response(1)
  • Monthly Mixtape(4)
  • A Day in the Life(5)
  • All About Jazz(96)
  • Awards(277)
  • Free MP3 Download of the Day(1775)
  • Around the World(205)
  • Between the Notes(36)
  • Book Club(95)
  • Celebrity Doppelganger(18)
  • Clash of the Cover Songs(49)
  • Coming Out Stories(24)
  • Concerts and Tours(6974)
  • Count Five(84)
  • Exclusive(6224)
  • Guest Blogger(138)
  • Holy Hell(1044)
  • I Fought the Law(117)
  • I Freakin' Love This Song(252)
  • In House(16)
  • Listen Up!(18)
  • Movies(433)
  • Music Appreciation(124)
  • New Music(993)
  • New Releases(744)
  • News(13004)
  • News Today, Oh Boy!(601)
  • PhotoSynthesis(88)
  • Picture Book(31)
  • Politics as Usual(66)
  • Pop Culture(94)
  • Potent Quotables(777)
  • Q + A(540)
  • Quizzes & Trivia(6)
  • R.I.P.(508)
  • Road Report(63)
  • Rock Almanac(366)
  • Rock Hall(51)
  • RPM(338)
  • Spinner Says(18)
  • Spinner Interview(217)
  • Television(269)
  • The Chum Bucket(777)
  • The Hit List(1402)
  • Twisted Tales(194)
  • Video(1885)
  • Video of the Day(1297)
  • What's That Song?(135)

Rockin' Caucus '07: Hottest Makeover

  • Posted on Dec 7th 2007 4:00PM by Spinner Staff
  • Comments
Email This
Winner: Carrie Underwood

Eat your heart out, Tony Romo. According to reader momanddalton, the Cowboys quarterback "doesn't know what he let go of" since moving from the "beautiful" Underwood to Jessica Simpson, who lacks "common sense."

Carrie Underwood ... 50%
Rihanna ... 28%
Alicia Keys ... 12%
Elliot Yamin ... 10%
Next Winner

  • Filed under: Rockin' Caucus
  • Email This

All the AOL Music info you want to know

Billboard Music Awards 2012 Winners List

AOL Music Blog

Ethan Miller, Getty Images for ABC The music industry stepped out for the…

Billboard Music Awards Red Carpet 2012…

AOL Music Blog

Getty (3) The Billboard Music Awards 2012 have kicked off, and with stars like…

Robin Gibb Dead at 62: Bee Gees Legend…

Spinner

Gareth Cattermole, Getty Images Robin Gibb, the singer, songwriter and…

See all AOL Music »

Add a Comment

Sign in »
*0 / 3000 Character Maximum
21

21 Comments

Filter by:
Anonymous

Come on everyone. Look at how young Britney was when she became famous. They had her prancing around in little midriff showing outfits. They had her in red pleather spacesuits. What did you think was going to be made of her? Did you honestly think that this young woman from Kentwood, Louisiana was going to stay normal? Come on people, can't you see that Britney is just like every single one of us? She's a human. She's a person. She just has a little more money than the rest of us, and shows up in magazines almost every week. Some of those stories aren't even true. Everyone says "Oh, well I heard this about Britney. And oh yeah, I heard that too. What a slut. What a bad role model." Okay, so she went out with no panties a few times. I'm sure that some of us have done that, but just because she's a celebrity, she gets put in a magazine for people to gossip about. Why? Because those sleazy paparazzi want to make some cash. I'm sure that if we left her alone for a while so she could clean herself up and get her life back together, everything would be better for her. This poor girl has been famous since she was, what, 17? It's pretty close to ten years that she's been famous. If we just got her out of the spotlight for a little while, she wouldn't be going so crazy. I mean, come on. Don't you tink she just needs a little time off from the media to make a huge comeback? Okay, so I'm an 11 year old. You don't have to listen to me. But you know what? I think you should all take some time to read this because I am speaking my mind about a regular person like us, who just has a little more cash than we do. Honestly, I think Britney just needs a little time to collect herself to make a big comeback. You go Britney! Keep trying girl!

~Anonymous

January 06 2008 at 10:32 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Jenah

I don't like Carrie Underwood. Jessica will always have a one-up on her. She's a contest winner...Jessica made herself.
And if this guy has it so bad without her, why is she the one saying it?

January 06 2008 at 12:13 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Taratova

As far as make over goes my choice is Elliott Yamin. He has changed in more ways that I can list. He was a shy guy and now he is the best Idol to me and so good to his fans. I had the great pleasure of meeting Elliott and hearing him sing live. His superstar quality attracted me to him. His vocals and style make it so easy to love his music . Plus Elliott did it with talent alone. No hype, big record label, just an independent artist making great music. He makes the songs real.

January 01 2008 at 12:39 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Boxberger

Why is Carrie even on the makeover list? This chick has been cute from day 1. I'm not in her fan club and buy all her music, but she's very talented and NATURALLY attractive. She has it going on in every way...always has. And while I'm at it, Alicia Keys looks the same as she did when she first came out as well. I'm not understanding this poll. The pickings must have been slim this year...

January 01 2008 at 2:04 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
joe roman

i love carrie underwood she's so pretty, and she's got great music. Britney spears made a big spectacle of herself in 2007. Hppy New Year everyone. Joe.

January 01 2008 at 2:00 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
joe roman

I love carrie underwood she's so pretty, and she has great music. Britney spears has really made a spectacle of herself in 2007.

January 01 2008 at 1:55 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
cjthomas211229

May the good lord be with you
Down every road you roam
And may sunshine and happiness
Surround you when youre far from home
And may you grow to be proud
Dignified and true
And do unto others
As youd have done to you
Be courageous and be brave
And in my heart youll always stay
Forever young, forever young
Forever young, forever young

May good fortune be with you
May your guiding light be strong
Build a stairway to heaven
With a prince or a vagabond

And may you never love in vain
And in my heart you will remain
Forever young, forever young
Forever young, forever young
Forever young
Forever young

And when you finally fly away
Ill be hoping that I served you well
For all the wisdom of a lifetime
No one can ever tell

Peace, Happy New Year

January 01 2008 at 1:37 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
CUNT HATER

carries music does nothing i saw the new years show the songs were bland she was bland

January 01 2008 at 1:26 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
patrick

wow! carrie underwood is talent,true beauty in and outside, and a real performance. i hear that she is a vegetarian, she has the love for all the livingthings, that is why she is always shinier than anybody else from within and out.
keep up the noble living style,
i love you carrie, God bless you!

January 01 2008 at 1:24 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
CHERYL KOZY

I AGREE CARRIE UNDERWOOD IS A VERY CLASS ACT AND SHE IS BEAUTIFUL, AND HAS A GREAT TALENT I JUST SAW HER ON ROCKIN NEW YEAR'S EVE AND SHE LOOKED GREAT, SHE IS SUCH A TALENTED WOMAN, HER PARENTS MUST BE SO PROUD OF HER, SHE'S A LADY IN EVERY WAY. KEEP IT UP CARRIE I REALLY ENJOY YOUR MUSIC, I PREDICTED YOU WOULD WIN ON AI. THE MINUTE I SAW YOU AUDITION I SAID THATS THE WINNER OF AI. I JUST FELT IT. GREAT JOB GIRL GOD BLESS YOU.

January 01 2008 at 12:57 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Load more comments

Follow Us

  • Newsletter
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Sign Up for Spinner's Newsletter! Get free MP3s, play a selection of each week's new albums free, read features, win sweet music swag and more!




  • Contact Us
  • Send News Tips
  • Advertise with Us

SIGN UP FOR SPINNER'S NEWSLETTER

  • Get free MP3s, play a selection of each week's new albums free, read features, win sweet music swag and more!

  • Sign Up!

AOL Radio

Listen to AOL Radio Now
play arrow
Top Indie - Today's best indie rock and pop
play arrow
Indie Rock Mix - A mix of new and old indie rock
play arrow
New Indie First - The latest in indie music
Online Radio Guide

Listen to Full CDs

  • Gossip, 'A Joyful Noise'
  • Tenacious D, 'Rize Of The Fenix'
  • Best Coast, 'The Only Place'
  • Beach House, 'Bloom'
  • The Cribs, 'In the Belly of the Brazen Bull'
  • Play More Albums Free

Most Popular

  • 17 of the Riskiest Moves in Music History: The Brave, Crazy and Inspirational
    Like

    91

  • Rihanna Twitter Pictures: See the Singer's Most Shocking Social Media Photo Shares
    Like

    62

  • Wayne Newton Sexual Harassment, Animal Abuse Allegations: Singer Sued Over Home Museum Plans
    Like

    133

  • Van Halen Cancel Summer Tour Dates
    Like

    709

  • Jay-Z Pauses Music Career, Janet Jackson Records New LP, Iggy Azalea Flaunts Booty & More
    Like

    16

  • PHOTOS: We 'Turn Back Time' On Cher's Wild Style
    Like

    264

  • Justin Bieber, Selena Gomez Split? Social Media Moves Lead to Breakup Speculation
    Like

    24

  • PHOTO: Mom's Public Punishment For Daughter's Facebook Pics
    Like

    5K

  • Lady Gaga, Philippines Protests: Pop Star Faces More Religious Demonstrators on Asian Leg of Tour
    Like

    22

  • PHOTOS: Thank Goodness For Double-Sided Tape...
    Like

    44

  • Who Wore It Better? Jennifer Lopez vs. Emma Stone's Snake Dress
    Like

    12

  • LOOK: Pictures From Sunday's Solar Eclipse
    Like

    2K

  • Lil Wayne, Assault: Photographer Says He Was Hit With Skateboard After Trying for Picture
    Like

    62

  • Kim Looks Elegant & 12 Other Best-Dressed Stars This Week
    Like

    10

  • Neil Young and Crazy Horse, 'Clementine' -- Exclusive Video Premiere
    Like

    4K

  • The Best And Worst Supermarket Dill Pickles
    Like

    180

  • PHOTOS: Kate, Charlene & All The World's Royals Party With Queen Elizabeth II
    Like

    68

  • PHOTOS: Ann Taylor LOFT Has Some Fun With Photoshop
    Like

    167

  • PHOTOS: The Queen Of Swaziland Is Into Some Totally Wacky (Read: Awesome) Fashion
    Like

    118

  • 14 Fascinating Facts About Solar Eclipses
    Like

    699

  • WATCH: SNL's Emotional Goodbye To Kristen Wiig
    Like

    6K

  • Mom Temporarily Banned From Uploading Photos To Facebook
    Like

    181

  • PHOTOS: Inside The World's First $1 Billion Home
    Like

    408

  • PHOTOS: Gorilla Overload!
    Like

    478

  • Pelosi Says Boehner 'Wants To Go Over The Edge'
    Like

    2K

  • Maher: Liberty University Is Not A Real School
    Like

    17K

  • How To See Sunday's Solar Eclipse
    Like

    6K

  • Zuckerberg Ties The Knot
    Like

    8K

  • Geraldo Rivera: Trayvon Martin Was 'Dressed In Thug Wear'
    Like

    2K

  • LOOK: Mesmerizing Macro Bug Photos
    Like

    2K

  • Tim Lihoreau: 11 People You Don't Want To Be Friends With
    Like

    133

  • ShermansTravel: PHOTOS: 5 Strange SkyMall Travel Products
    Like

    315

  • Grandma Gets Life In Prison For First-Time Drug Offense
    Like

    2K

Also on AOL

Quick Links

  • Slipknot Masks
  • Saddest Songs
  • Funny Music Videos
  • SXSW 2011

Also on AOL Music

  • Concert Tickets
  • Grammys 2012
  • Music Videos
  • New Music Releases

Blogs on AOL

  • Country Music
  • Hip Hop Music
  • Metal Music
  • Pop Music News

More on AOL

  • Best Lyrics
  • Best Metal Songs
  • Break Up Songs
  • Online Radio

More on AOL

  • Christmas Music
  • Classic Rock Songs
  • Best Songs of 2010
  • SHOUTcast

Help Links

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • About Our Ads
  • Follow Spinner on Twitter
  • The Interface
  • Free MP3
  • Full CDs
  • RSS

Spinner.com © 2012 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.