Former Shins Drummer Says He Was Fired
- Posted on Aug 7th 2009 11:30AM by John D. Luerssen
- Comments (33)
Former Shins drummer Jesse Sandoval says he was sacked by frontman James Mercer after a 16-year working relationship. Following Mercer's cryptic answers on why the band's lineup, which also saw the forced exit of longtime keyboardist/bassist Marty Crandall, shifted, Sandoval has spilled the beans in a new interview with the Portland Mercury."I unequivocally got fired, and it kind of confuses me why [Mercer] has a hard time saying that," Sandoval said. "I understand he's probably doing it out of respect for me reading interviews, it might be hard for him to say it, but ... I got fired. There's no other way of looking at it."
Earlier this year, Mercer told Pitchfork it was "an aesthetic decision". Sandoval -- who has since opened a Portland lunch truck called Nuevo in honor of his New Mexican roots -- was initially hesitant to open up about being discharged.
"We played our last Christmas festival run of shows for radio," Sandoval said. "It was in Atlanta, and in all honestly, I definitely remember walking offstage and calling my girlfriend and saying, 'I don't know why, but I just have a feeling like this is it. I feel like this is probably my last Shins show.' And it wasn't coming from my end, I just had this feeling."
After a long break at Mercer's request following the lengthy promotional efforts behind 2007's 'Wincing the Night Away', Sandoval said he hadn't heard from Mercer so he contacted him. "I'd caught wind from a couple people that James was processing moving further along with the idea of working with other people, but I never quite got the impression that it was going be an across-the-board change." Sandoval said.
Mercer ultimately sacked Sandoval by phone. "You could tell in his voice that it was really hard," Sandoval continued. "He started to explain his thought processes and his reasoning and, of course, I'm shocked. Even though I knew it was going to happen, I was shocked ... There was nothing. There was no follow-up."
Despite all this, Sandoval says he directs no ill will toward Mercer or the Shins 2.0. "I wanted my answers to be out there so every time I do any sort of press for the [food] cart and what I'm doing in my life, I don't have to repeat myself," he explained. "Also something that's been bothering me is a lot of people have been saying, 'I'm never going to buy another Shins album again! How can James Mercer do that?' And I have my reasons to be angry at James, but I don't want to be a part of any sort of movement where everybody's against the Shins."











Reader Comments(1 of 2)
Rockyat 8-08-2009
Band, I thought it was a noise machine
Mattat 8-08-2009
Um, who ARE these people???
Wish Belkinat 8-08-2009
Never heard of the band or these people, but this Mercer fellow sounds like a dick.
Jess Sandovalat 8-10-2009
Mercer is a Dick! I am Jesse's father, and I was a drummer, but I never had the natural talent that Jesse possessed. Jesse was the Shins and the Shins was Jesse because of the drum beat. He was a natural. The Shins will never be the same, even though Mercer was quite mellow and creative and important to the group, he will likely not have the success that he had with the Shins. Best wishes for the greatest Dick.
Darylat 8-08-2009
From a fan, not a promoter: The Shins are a fabulously unique indy-rock sound based in Portland, OR. They've had a few pretty big and beautiful,popular radio hits, which I'm pretty sure a lot of folks will recognize. They have been on either Letterman or Leno, don't recall which. I love them!
vbeek2002at 8-08-2009
The Shins are BORING and they SUCK. Ronald f-ing McDonald could play drums for them with Burger King on harmonica and Dairy Queen as the road whore STILL no one would care. Don't ask me why I chose fast food icons, but The Shins are BORING BORING BORING.
Larryat 8-08-2009
I thought shins were what you hurt when you bumped the lower front part of your legs.. Sounds more interesting,anyway
kevinat 8-08-2009
WHO?! and why is this news?
SPIKE IS THE DOGat 8-08-2009
Oh, C'mon now...THE SHINS??? Who the hell are they??? Let's get some REAL news about a band that is known by people and who actually have music people have heard. before. And Johny at the garage band down the street lost his guitar pick...that's news too I guess.
stimpyat 8-08-2009
shins? who cares lol. They will never add up to godsmack,kiss,beatles,or metallica,and many more.
yoat 8-08-2009
wtf godsmack?!
Cyraat 9-02-2009
Perhaps those who have nothing nice to say shouldn't say anything at all.
And maybe this is news because obviously no one else knew about it....?
Dawgat 8-08-2009
Never heard of them.
ThreeThreeThreeat 8-08-2009
I bought Wincing The Night Away. Great album. But I thought "The Shins" meant they were a band. Not sure why the frontman James Mercer, makes firing decisions... besides frontmen are usually strange egomaniacs anyway. I'm a musician and we joke about it all the time. We call it LVS. Lead Vocalist Syndrome.
vgkflcat 8-08-2009
I have never heard of these guys at all till now and this is news?????????????????????????????????
Pissedat 8-08-2009
16 years you played with this guy and we still never heard of you or the band??? What did you do for money all that time live with mommy??? Get a real job 'cause that one didn't work!!!!
Tarabearat 8-08-2009
I'm a fan of The Shins. Thank you for the article. Their music may be boring to you, but it just mellows me out and calms me down. I like it a lot!
SamBlobat 8-08-2009
I cannot say the music is boring to me because I have never heard it. At all. And they've been around for fifteen years...
oraznalat 8-08-2009
my favorites are from the self absorbed schmucks who think that since they never heard of something, it can't possibly be news. You know, because the world must revolve around them or something.
tananat 8-08-2009
I hear Led Zepplin has a need for a drummer....