• AOL
  • MAIL
    • You might also like: 
    • Music | 
    • Movies | 
    • TV | 
    • Celebrity
    •  and More
    • Main
    • News
    • Features
      • The Hit List
      • Spinner Interview
      • Potent Quotables
      • Guest Blogger
    • Songs
      • MP3 of the Day
      • Listening Party
      • What's That Song?
    • Videos
      • The Interface
      • Sessions
      • Video of the Day
    • Our Widgets
      • iPhone App
      • Radio Toolbar
    • Send Feedback

    Spinner Exclusives

    • The Interface - Live Performances
    • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free
    • Spinner Radio
    • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free

    Features

    • Bad Song, Good Band
    • Bands With Brothers
    • Banned Bands
    • Outrageous Tribute Bands
    • Sad Songs
    • Worst Lyrics Ever

    All Categories

    • Spinner Says(7)
    • All About Jazz(26)
    • Clash of the Cover Art(1)
    • Lyrics(4)
    • Music A-Z(24)
    • New Releases(53)
    • Quizzes & Trivia(2)
    • Album(110)
    • Around the World(147)
    • Book Club(57)
    • Canada(318)
    • Celebrity Doppelganger(13)
    • Clash of the Cover Songs(45)
    • Coming Out Stories(20)
    • Concerts and Tours(1666)
    • Count Five(63)
    • Country(45)
    • Electronic(274)
    • Exclusive(2432)
    • Free MP3 Download of the Day(898)
    • Grammy Awards(87)
    • Guest Blogger(61)
    • Holy Hell(644)
    • I Fought the Law(31)
    • I Freakin' Love This Song(238)
    • Jazz(16)
    • Laugh, Rage, Cry(6)
    • Movies(163)
    • Music Appreciation(50)
    • New Music(304)
    • News(4713)
    • Politics as Usual(19)
    • Pop Culture(40)
    • Potent Quotables(613)
    • R.I.P.(184)
    • Road Report(17)
    • Rock Almanac(366)
    • Rock Hall(29)
    • RPM(25)
    • Schwag Hag(37)
    • Songs(201)
    • Spinner Interview(110)
    • Television(94)
    • The Chum Bucket(606)
    • The Crap Stack(17)
    • The Hit List(1128)
    • Total Dick Move(2)
    • Twisted Tales(125)
    • UK(512)
    • Video(923)
    • Video of the Day(707)
    • Wacked News(190)
    • What's That Song?(79)

    Rock's Biggest Quitters: 20 Musicians Who Walked Away From Fame

    • Posted   by Spinner Staff
    • Comments (202)
    Print |  Email More

    They say winners never quit, but in the music biz there's something to be said for going out at the top of your game. Whether they left for greener pastures, fled amid feuds and controversy, or just dropped off the face of the earth, here are some of the biggest quitters in rock music history.

    D'arcy Wretzky

    D'Arcy Quits the Smashing Pumpkins:

    After five albums with the Smashing Pumpkins, bassist D'Arcy Wretzky ditched the notoriously difficult Billy Corgan (and ex-fiancé James Iha), which Corgan later blamed on D'Arcy's drug and emotional problems. D'Arcy played briefly in other bands before leaving the industry altogether to "pursue other interests." Those interests included owning an antique store, living on a horse farm, becoming a masseuse -- and recently entailed calling a Chicago radio station to inquire about Davy Jones of the Monkees.




    Zack de la Rocha

    Zack de la Rocha Quits Rage Against the Machine:

    Zack de la Rocha and Rage Against the Machine stuck it to The Man with their politically incendiary hits, but in 2000 the fiery frontman quit the band at the peak of their fame, citing the ever-popular "creative differences." While his former bandmates joined Chris Cornell to form Audioslave, de la Rocha toiled on an abortive solo album and a never-released collaboration with Trent Reznor. RATM reunited for some festival appearances in 2007-08, but the band's future remains uncertain.



    Lauryn Hill

    Lauryn Hill Quits Singing (and Rapping and Acting):

    The Axl Rose of the neo-soul crowd, Lauryn Hill went from superstar to super ... hermit. A hip-hop sensation with the Fugees in the late 1990s -- and 'Sister Act 2' movie star -- Hill struck platinum with 'The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill' in 1998 before dropping out to focus on motherhood, religion and a new album that's been "in development" for more than a decade. Despite an awkwardly conceived 'MTV Unplugged' and a brief 2004 Fugees reunion, Hill remains a troubling enigma.



    Jason Newsted

    Jason Newsted Quits Metallica:

    When Metallica bassist Cliff Burton died in 1986, Jason Newsted won the most coveted gig on the mullet circuit. Despite his good fortune, he quit in 2001 when his side project, Echobrain, led James Hetfield to question Newsted's commitment to the Biggest Metal Band on Earth. When Echobrain fizzled, Newsted joined Voivod and toured with Ozzy Osbourne, and in 2006 he joined a cast of washed-up rockers on the less-than-successful "supergroup" reality show 'Rock Star: Supernova.'



    Abba

    Abba Couples Quit Each Other and Music:

    'Mamma Mia!' had audiences dancing in the aisles, but not even an entirely new generation of fans -- or a reported offer of $1 billion in 2000 -- could entice the Swedish pop deities out of retirement. One of the best-selling groups ever, Abba disbanded in the early 1980s following the divorces of both couples. They've since vowed never to perform together again, no matter how much 'Money, Money, Money' they're offered.





    Ace Frehley

    Ace Frehley Quits Kiss (Twice):

    They called him Space Ace, but "head case" might've been more appropriate. In the early 1980s, the substance-addled lead guitarist quit the band in disgust at its move toward disco and concept albums. The fans seemed to agree, as both a separated Kiss and Frehley encountered only mild success until they all put their makeup back on for a 1996 reunion tour. True to form, he left the band again after its 2002 "farewell" tour.





    Rob Halford

    Rob Halford Quits Both Judas Priest and Hiding His Sexuality:

    Boasting a feverish guitar attack and Rob Halford's distinctive wail, Judas Priest brought leather-and-spikes metal to the mainstream with such Beavis and Butt-head–approved headbangers as 'Breakin' the Law.' When self-proclaimed "metal god" Halford exited the band in 1991 over "creative differences," he was famously replaced by a fan (inspiring the unfortunate Mark Wahlberg film 'Rock Star'). After fronting other bands, Halford made headlines when he announced his homosexuality in 1998. The newly liberated singer rejoined Priest in 2003.



    John Lennon

    John Lennon Secretly Quits the Beatles:

    The blame has been placed on Yoko's shoulders, but the Beatles' breakup was going to happen sooner or later. After a long period of infighting, Lennon officially resigned from the band in 1969, asking his bandmates to keep it private so they could "work it out" legally. But the cat was let out of the bag when Paul McCartney released his solo debut in 1970, triggering a spate of lawsuits that took years to settle.





    Natalie Merchant

    Natalie Merchant Quits 10,000 Maniacs, Leaving 9,999 Maniacs:

    After years as indie darlings, the Natalie Merchant–led 10,000 Maniacs finally hit their commercial stride in 1993 with 'Our Time in Eden,' which spawned the hits 'These Are Days' and 'Candy Everybody Wants.' So how did Merchant celebrate? By leaving the band. Her first two solo efforts, 'Tigerlily' and 'Ophelia,' were hugely successful with adult alternative audiences, and though subsequent albums have seen diminishing returns, she remains popular with the hemp-and-organic-vegetable set.



    Michael Nesmith

    Michael Nesmith Quits the Monkees:

    In the Monkees, Michael Nesmith was clearly destined for better things. That's why in 1970 he asked to be released from his contract. Nesmith became a pioneer of both country-rock and music video production, and in 1980 he sold the concept to what would become MTV. Not that he needed the money, being the heir to the Liquid Paper fortune -- freeing him from the need to bash out 'Last Train to Clarksville' at state fairs.





    Prince

    Prince Quits Being Prince:

    Quitting a band is one thing, but how do you quit being yourself? In 1993, to prove a point to his record company, the mercurial superstar changed his name to a symbol. So what's in a name? Well, the "Artist Formerly Known as Prince" years coincided with some of the weakest music of his career, so let's just say everyone was happy when he once again proclaimed, 'My Name Is Prince.'





    Steve Perry

    Steve Perry Quits Journey:

    Steve Perry led Journey from 1978 until he and the band went their "separate ways" in 1987. Despite early solo success with 'Oh Sherrie,' by 1995 he was ready to resume knocking out power ballads with his former bandmates. Perry retuned to the sidelines after a 1998 hip injury -- and has since been replaced by pint-sized Filipino karaoke star Arnel Pineda -- but if he asked nicely, the band would surely welcome him back with "open arms."




    Dee Dee Ramone

    Dee Dee Ramone Quits the Ramones for Rap:

    Dee Dee Ramone can be credited with giving the band not only its name but also its signature punk sound. But in 1989, after 15 years in the Ramones, he said, "Hey ho, let's go" and left to pursue, of all things, a rap career. Although his solo endeavors failed miserably, Dee Dee continued to write songs for the Ramones until his death from a heroin overdose in 2002.




    Cat Stevens

    Cat Stevens Quits Music for Religion:

    Cat Stevens, born Steven Georgiou, sold millions of copies of his touchy-feely folk rock. But after nearly drowning in 1976, Stevens began searching for higher meaning. He converted to Islam, changed his name (again) to Yusuf Islam and auctioned off his guitars for charity. Though praised for his philanthropy, Yusuf's support of Islamic charities landed him on an FBI watch list in 2004. Fortunately, his name was cleared in time to promote his 2006 return album.




    Izzy Stradlin

    Izzy Stradlin Quits Guns N' Roses:

    Considering how long it took Axl Rose to release 'Chinese Democracy,' Izzy Stradlin knew well enough to quit Guns N' Roses while he was ahead. In 1991, the guitarist had seen enough of the booze, drugs and egos surrounding him, and he left the band during the 'Use Your Illusion' tour -- hence the famous "Where's Izzy?" sign in the 'November Rain' video. No hard feelings, though: Stradlin still fills in at the occasional G'n'R gig, most recently in 2006.




    Mase

    Mase Quits Rap for the Ministry:

    After a long stint as P. Diddy's sidekick, Mase broke out on the Notorious B.I.G.'s megahit 'Mo Money Mo Problems,' and his 1997 debut album, 'Harlem World,' blew up multiplatinum. But then "rap's newest bad boy" found Jesus after an arrest for soliciting a prostitute. After his second album sagged, Mase quit the biz to become neither a baller nor a shot-caller but instead a minister. His failed 2004 comeback album, 'Welcome Back,' needed some divine intervention.



    Tom Fogerty

    Tom Fogerty Quits on His Brother in Creedence:

    The musical interplay between brothers Tom and John Fogerty fueled Creedence Clearwater Revival, but with frontman and songwriter John getting all the attention, fraternal tensions boiled over and Tom quit the band in 1971. While he continued to make music and perform on his own, Tom's strained relationship with his sibling culminated in a lawsuit over CCR royalties. Although the suit was successful, Tom Fogerty died tragically in 1990 after contracting AIDS from a blood transfusion.



    Holly Johnson

    Holly Johnson Quits Frankie Goes to Hollywood:

    A mere three years after the global success of 'Relax' in 1984, Frankie Goes to Hollywood frontman Holly Johnson quit the band over, what else, creative differences. After winning a landmark court case to get out of his contract, the openly gay Liverpool native found some solo success with a new label, but upon learning he was HIV positive in 1991, Johnson left the music business to focus on painting. Frankie -- and Frankie's physicians -- say relax.



    Brian Wilson

    Brian Wilson Quits Touring With the Beach Boys:

    Brian Wilson set the template for the Tortured Rock Genius. The Beach Boys leader had scored hit after hit in the early 1960s with 'Surfin' U.S.A.' and 'I Get Around,' but soon Wilson wasn't having any 'Fun, Fun. Fun.' He stopped touring in 1964 and eventually had a breakdown while trying to perfect his magnum opus, 'Smile.' Showing he's not a complete quitter, a much-improved Wilson finally released 'Smile' in 2004, a mere 38 years after he started it.



    Noel Gallagher

    Noel Gallagher Quits Oasis (Finally):

    When Oasis announced they wouldn't be taking the stage at a Paris music festival in August 2009, the crowd thought it was a joke. But after a wicked backstage fight, Noel Gallagher quit the band, declaring he couldn't "go on working with Liam a day longer." Noel and Liam aren't exactly the poster boys for brotherly love -- they once got in a fistfight over their favorite Christmas song -- but despite their many well-publicized feuds, this is Noel's first official departure.




    No Singer? No Problem! 20 Replacement Singers
    • Filed under: The Hit List
    • Share & Bookmark :
      Print |  Email More

    Reader Comments(1 of 11)

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    SCOTT IRONSat 9-17-2009

    Natalie Merchant leaving 10,000 Maniacs was the most devastating of the quitters in this list.

    Merchant's vocals are the greatest in the world. That band died when she left.

    Reply
    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Kathleenat 9-20-2009

    Agreed, and perhaps subsequent albums have not cultivated many new Natalie Merchant fans but if you were already a fan you loved Motherland and 'Carpenters Daughter as much as Tigerlily.

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Moabat 9-20-2009

    Yeah but she went on to do the solo albums which were great. I hope she does something else.Love her music and lyrics.

    vote downvote upReportHighest Ranked

    Jenat 9-21-2009

    The sign that read "Where's Izzy" was in Guns N' Roses' video for "Don't Cry," not "November Rain."

    vote downvote upReportLow Ranked

    Othman Azizat 10-06-2009

    I agree too. I love her angelic voice !

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Rayat 10-14-2009

    Supposedly, Natalie was ready to move on and told the band prior to the "Our Time in Eden" tour. She had been with the guys since the early 80s and was ready for a change. They did record the highly successful "Unplugged" CD after "Our Time in Eden" which I am sure eased the breakup for the band. BTW, the guitarist for the band, Rob Buck, passed away several years ago. I am hoping Natalie returns to more of her indie rock roots in the future, but she got married a few years ago and has a young child now, so who knows. But in 1993, there was no more beautiful and fabulous star than Natalie.

    vote downvote upReportHighest Ranked

    Farnorthat 9-18-2009

    Brian didn't so much quit the Beach Boys, as they quit him. Somehow the Beatles were allowed by fans, record companies and critics to go from I Wanna Hold Your Hand to A Day in the Life. However, the fans, the record companies and especially Mike Love wanted more Surfin' USA and less Pet Sounds. Mike's famous comments were, "Don't f*ck with the formula," and "Brian's ego music." In the end it didn't matter as drugs and depression damaged Brian so much that he was not able to participate any longer other than some generally weak studio work. With Dennis a mess, Mike, Carl, Bruce and Al soldiered on with "the traveling juke box." Ultimately they survived Jimi and Janis, disco, new wave, punk and rap to firmly entrench nostalgia as a continuing art form. And, for the last 20 years, the Brian-o-philes (and a growing number of afficianados) have celebrated Brian's return to the stage and studio. It's amazing that brian is the last Wilson standing.

    Reply
    vote downvote upReportHighest Ranked

    shamrockdoc68at 9-20-2009

    Farnoth, you are a great writer. You gave a lot of interesting information and you truly seem to know what you are talking about. You should be writing professionally if you do not already. 'Well written!

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Davidat 10-14-2009

    REALLY well written and thought out ... I couldn't agree more regarding Brian and his brothers/cousins. Regarding the article though, I thought they were going to focus on Lennon's quitting music all together to become the house dad after Sean was born. This was during his "baking bread" years with Yoko, when he totally left the music business. He didn't really leave the biz after his divorce from the Beatles, recording as the Plastic Ono Band. Later on, after his prolonged "retirement", he returned with "Double Fantasy", shortly before his death.

    vote downvote upReportHighest Ranked

    Jed Cleverat 9-21-2009

    How come Brian Jones of the rolling Stones is not on this list? He was the first "rock casualty" of the '60's, dying shortly after quitting (or some say forced out of) the Stones. He was a true musical genius, and could figure out how to play just about any instrument in a short perior of time. RIP Brian

    Reply
    vote downvote upReportHighest Ranked

    Nancy Gat 9-20-2009

    I am waiting for the s--- to hit the fan and the truth will come out that Brian Jones was murdered...he never would have committed suicide, and he was the REAL leading force behind the Stones, not Mick...

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Sharonat 10-07-2009

    Did Brian Jones quit or was he fired?

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Mike Cat 10-14-2009

    Mostly agree with you Nancy, but the battle between "leading force" of the Stones was more of a Keith Richards / Brian Jones battle. Mick's most influential period with the Stones was during the 70s, which coincided with Keith's worst drug years. By the end of the decade, Keith had become much more functional, and make no mistake about it, the Stones is his band.

    Btw, listen to Mick and Keith's solo albums and it's obvious that Keith's records sound like the Stones without Mick, while Mick's sound like Mick Jagger in studio musician hell.

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    jagerandreaat 10-14-2009

    Brian Jones was kicked out of the band; he did not quit. He died 3 months later---all of it very tragic, but he did not quit.

    vote downvote upReportHigh Ranked

    Jed Cleverat 10-14-2009

    I would agree that Brian was more or less forced out of the band, as opposed to quitting. There are a lot of murky issues as to what exactly happened the night Brian died, e.g., an accidental drowning, murder (by way of Thorogood and/or Keylock?), possible involvement by Mick and Keith (to avoid paying the $100,000 per year promised to him upon his “resignation”), and other nefarious activities (such as all his guitars and valuables disappearing right after his death). What is indisputable is that the Stones HAD to tour the States to support Let It Bleed, as they were broke, and Brian could not get a visa due to his numerous drug busts. (Mick and Keith still could, as they only had one misdemeanor drug bust each). Its is also questionable whether Brian had the physical and mental stamina to survive a tour. So, from a purely business perspective, Brian HAD to go. The mysterious question is, how?

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Charlesat 9-19-2009

    How bad is your luck when you get caught soliciting a prostitute. Yeah I can see how that would make you go to church.

    Reply
    vote downvote upReportLowest Ranked

    chelleat 10-06-2009

    I believe that's where MASE,you,and I should be in the church. JESUS is coming back soon,Will you be ready for the judgement seat of CHRIST?

    vote downvote upReportLowest Ranked

    molochat 9-19-2009

    i wish bruce springsteen would quit. that BABY was born to suck balls. and poison needs to quit while their behind. BEHIND

    Reply
    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    Garyat 10-13-2009

    My thoughts exactly.

    vote downvote upReportNeutral

    housequakeat 10-14-2009

    u r so right lol !

    12345 Next >

    Add your comments

    • New Users
    • Returning Users
    • AOL/AIM Screenname

    If you are posting a comment for the first time, please enter your name and email address in the fields above. Your name will be displayed with your comment. Your email address will never be displayed.

    Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Off-topic, promotional or otherwise inappropriateinappropriate comments will be removed.

    When you enter your name and email address for the first time, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, as well as a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

    Follow US

    Facebook
    Twitter
    RSS
    • Contact Us
    • Send News Tips
    • Advertise with Us

    Shop Now

    Listen to Full CDs

    • Hot Chip, 'One Life Stand'
    • Sade, 'Soldier of Love'Massive Attack, 'Heligoland'
    • Return of the Wu & Friends
    • Dave Matthews & Tim Reynolds
    • All Spinner Full CDs

    Relevant Posts

    • Bands With Brothers: From Love -- to Love to Hate (55 days ago - 218 Comments)
    • 10 Best Whistling Parts in Songs (29 days ago - 160 Comments)
    • The Grammy Awards' Biggest Mistakes (14 days ago - 16 Comments)
    • 20 Outrageous Tribute Bands (16 days ago - 74 Comments)
    • Soundgarden Reuniting in 2010 (39 days ago - 4 Comments)

    Billboard

    • 1: Break, Three Days Grace
    • 2: Uprising, Muse
    • 3: Your Decision, Alice In Chains
    • 4: If You Only Knew, Shinedown
    • 5: (If You're Wondering If I Want You To) I Want You To, Weezer
    • See All Top 100 Rock Albums at

    Hottest Artists on Tour: Lady GaGa, Taylor Swift, Pink, Black Eyed Peas, Kid Cudi,

    Also on AOL

    Quick Links

    • Celebrity Tattoos
    • Celebrities Without Makeup
    • Slipknot Masks
    • Christmas Music
    • 50s Music
    • 60s Music
    • 90s Music
    • 70s Music
    • 80s Music
    • Best Songs Of 2008
    • Horrorcore
    • Michael Jackson Songs

    Also on AOL Music

    • Concert Tickets
    • Country Music
    • Grammys
    • Hip Hop Music
    • Lyrics
    • Metal Music
    • Music News
    • Music Videos
    • New Music Releases
    • Online Radio
    • PopEater

    Blogs on AOL

    • Autoblog
    • Be Red
    • BloggingStocks
    • Cinematical
    • DownloadSquad
    • Engadget
    • Fanhouse
    • Joystiq
    • StyleList
    • TMZ

    More on AOL

    • African-American Culture
    • AOL Video
    • Breaking News
    • CityGuide
    • Food
    • Love
    • Media Player
    • Musica Latina
    • Pixcetera
    • Singles
    • Wallet Pop

    More on AOL

    • Television
    • Movies
    • Money
    • Mapquest
    • Horoscopes
    • Health
    • AOL Latino
    • Games
    • SHOUTcast

    Help Links

    • Advertise With Us
    • Mail
    • Notify AOL
    • Privacy Policy
    • Search
    • Terms of Service
    • Trademarks
    • Follow Spinner on Twitter
    • The Interface
    • Free Mp3
    • Full CDs
    • RSS
    • Terms of Use

    Spinner.com © 2009 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.