• AOL
  • MAIL
    • You might also like: 
    • Music | 
    • Movies | 
    • TV | 
    • Celebrity News
    •  and More
    Sign In / Register
Spinner
  • Main
  • Spinner RPM
  • Features
    • The Hit List
    • Spinner Interview
    • Tributes & Essays
    • Music Appreciation
  • Songs
    • Free MP3 of the Day
    • Play Full Albums Free
  • Videos
    • The Interface
    • Sessions
    • Video of the Day
    • All Videos
  • Radio
    • AOL Radio
    • AOL Radio Toolbar
    • Shoutcast
  • AOL Music Sites
    • The Boot
    • The BoomBox
    • Noisecreep
    • AOL Music Blog
  • SXSW
  • Send Feedback
  • Madonna

    Watch Madonna Halftime Show
  • Taylor Swift

    Watch Taylor Swift Beatboxing
  • Katy Perry

    Get Katy Perry News
  • Kristin Chenoweth

    Watch Kristin Chenoweth in Our Studio
  • Ringo Starr

    Read Ringo Starr Interview
  • Janet Jackson

    Super Bowl Halftime Bloopers
  • Kellie Pickler

    Read Kellie Pickler Interview
  • Chris Brown

    Chris Brown 'Wins' Unwelcome Award

Spinner Exclusives

  • The Interface - Live Performances
  • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free
  • Spinner Radio
  • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free

Features

  • Best Songs 2011
  • Top Albums of 2011
  • Sad Songs
  • Music Geeks in Film
  • Best Opening Lyrics

All Categories

  • Monthly Mixtape(1)
  • A Day in the Life(5)
  • All About Jazz(96)
  • Awards(229)
  • Free MP3 Download of the Day(1671)
  • Around the World(205)
  • Between the Notes(36)
  • Book Club(94)
  • Celebrity Doppelganger(18)
  • Clash of the Cover Songs(49)
  • Coming Out Stories(23)
  • Concerts and Tours(6839)
  • Count Five(83)
  • Exclusive(5972)
  • Guest Blogger(133)
  • Holy Hell(1016)
  • I Fought the Law(111)
  • I Freakin' Love This Song(252)
  • In House(12)
  • Listen Up!(18)
  • Movies(424)
  • Music Appreciation(123)
  • New Music(857)
  • New Releases(613)
  • News(12253)
  • PhotoSynthesis(88)
  • Picture Book(31)
  • Politics as Usual(61)
  • Pop Culture(92)
  • Potent Quotables(776)
  • Q + A(492)
  • Quizzes & Trivia(6)
  • R.I.P.(454)
  • Road Report(61)
  • Rock Almanac(366)
  • Rock Hall(44)
  • RPM(260)
  • Spinner Says(15)
  • Spinner Interview(212)
  • Television(243)
  • The Chum Bucket(777)
  • The Hit List(1388)
  • Twisted Tales(194)
  • Video(1781)
  • Video of the Day(1223)
  • What's That Song?(134)

Clash of the Cover Songs: Michael Jackson vs. Imogen Heap

  • Posted on Oct 28th 2009 2:45PM by Ashley Iasimone
  • Comments
Email This
The Rules for Battle: Each week, we pit versions of the same song by two different artists in a head-to-head death match for musical supremacy. (Sometimes it will be the original recording vs. a cover version; other times it will be two different covers.) Then it's up to you to decide: Listen to and vote on which version you think should emerge victorious and which should be sent packing. May the best band win!

Michael Jackson and Imogen Heap

The Song: 'Thriller' (original version by Michael Jackson)

The Contestants: Michael Jackson vs. Imogen Heap

In This Corner -- Michael Jackson: With Halloween right around the corner, we'll undoubtedly be hearing the late King of Pop's chilling classic a lot this week. The 1982 song -- and its epic 14-minute dance-with-the-undead video -- became a signature for Jackson; the groove of its bassline, paired with Michaels killer vocals and sleek moves, produced a frighteningly great single.

Michael Jackson, 'Thriller'


In This Corner -- Imogen Heap: Being put up against a recording from the best-selling album of all time? No pressure. Still, covering the track for BBC Radio 2, the brave English singer makes the song spooky in her own way. The attitude and beat of Jackson's original version is replaced with soft vocals and some hauntingly pretty piano. With such a mesmerizing transformation, it's pretty easy to believe that "something evil's lurking in the dark."

Imogen Heap, 'Thriller'


Next Clash
  • Filed under: Clash of the Cover Songs
  • Email This

All the AOL Music info you want to know

Killswitch Engage Welcome Back Original…

Noisecreep

KillswitchEngage.com After weeks of online speculation, it looks like…

Brandy and Monica's 'It All Belongs to…

The Boombox

Jason Merritt, Getty Images What a difference 14 years make. Back in 1998,…

Leslie Carter Death: Nick Carter Skips…

AOL Music Blog

Chad Buchanan, Getty Images Leslie Carter was laid to rest over the weekend…

See all AOL Music »

Add a Comment

Sign in »
*0 / 3000 Character Maximum
37

49 Comments

Filter by:
rikstik71664

got to give this one to the pedophile

May 25 2010 at 1:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
J-DooB

IS THIS A JOKE! Michael Jackson vs Imogen Heap! NO F'in WAY!

Michael Jackson ALL THE WAY! I grew up on that, and sappy crap is NOT why thriller was so much better. The Imogen Heap version sounds like a rape song or something, whatever that means. But that's the vibe I get.

March 05 2010 at 10:39 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Time

lol...R U Serious about the poll... that was freakin awful and a waist... oops... a waste of my time. I got through 3 bars and knew immediately it was a trick or treat prank. Definately a trick and certainly not a treat. Go get some vocal lessons and leave the King of Pop alone.

October 30 2009 at 7:15 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
imfoldin

It is obvious to me that none of you morons has studied music! If you listen carefully to the words and close your eyes it becomes clear that Imogen Heap is a much more sophisticated interpretation of this song. Michael could dance but he sure couldn't sing!!

October 30 2009 at 7:01 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
kaj

not. even. close.

October 30 2009 at 4:23 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Jean F

Lenny, Lenny, Lenny... why did you have to bring the race thing into this? Maybe Dan is not white? What would make you think that way? I happen to be white and I think MJ is still awesome!

October 30 2009 at 4:08 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Clyde

Obviously this lady is giving tribute to Michael. If she were not, she would not be singing HIS song. Why insult her or him by comparing their versions of HIS song. Isn't singing with heart and conviction what it's all about. (She certainly does that) When did Americans become so insensitive. You all are wasting the internet. Get a life.

October 30 2009 at 3:10 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Julie

I liked Imogen's version a lot. She has a unique and pretty voice. Hard to decide which version I like better. They each evoke something completely different. Michael's version is exciting (THRILLing even) and fun, and Imogen's is haunting and beautiful. Not fair to compare.

October 30 2009 at 10:51 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
vaglockgirl

I'D LIKE TO KNEW WHO THE HECK THE 9% IS THAT VOTED THIS CRAP WAS ANYWHERE CLOSE TO MJ. THERE IS NO COMPARISON, SHE CAN'T EVEN SING!!!! UGGH!

October 30 2009 at 9:17 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Pirate Jack

I am not a Micheal Jackson fan and i never will be one. I will say that his version of THRILLER is alot better than her version.The best parts of the song are the basslines and Vincent Price talking at the end.

October 30 2009 at 8:14 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Load more comments

Follow Us

  • Newsletter
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Sign Up for Spinner's Newsletter! Get free MP3s, play a selection of each week's new albums free, read features, win sweet music swag and more!




  • Contact Us
  • Send News Tips
  • Advertise with Us

SIGN UP FOR SPINNER'S NEWSLETTER

  • Get free MP3s, play a selection of each week's new albums free, read features, win sweet music swag and more!

  • Sign Up!

AOL Radio

Listen to Slacker AOL Radio Now
play arrow
Top Indie - Today's best indie rock and pop
play arrow
Indie Rock Mix - A mix of new and old indie rock
play arrow
New Indie First - The latest in indie music
Online Radio Guide

Listen to Full CDs

  • Paul McCartney, 'Kisses on the Bottom'
  • Sharon Van Etten, 'Tramp'
  • AIR, 'Le Voyage Dans La Lune'
  • Bahamas, 'Barchords'
  • Band of Skulls, 'Sweet Sour'
  • Play More Albums Free

Most Popular

  • Madonna Super Bowl Halftime Show: Romans, Cheerleaders and MIA's Middle Finger
    Like

    165

  • Super Bowl Halftime Bloopers: 10 Huge Mistakes on the Big Stage
    Like

    322

  • Puddle of Mudd Singer Arrested in January for Drug Possession
    Like

    115

  • Randy Travis Arrested in Texas
    Like

    189

  • Cee Lo's Super Bowl Strip Club Outing: Singer Reportedly Drops $10K
    Like

    36

  • Jennifer Lopez, Tori Spelling And More: The 15 Worst-Dressed Celebrities Of The Week
    Like

    54

  • Lil Kim's Tax Trouble: Queen Bee Owes IRS More Than $1 Million
    Like

    102

  • Komen Foundation Makes Stunning Reversal
    Like

    21K

  • Christina Aguilera Family Trauma: Singer Considers Reconciling With Long-Estranged Father
    Like

    33

  • Teen With No Hands Kept Off SeaWorld And Universal Rides
    Like

    747

  • Miranda Lambert's Dog Dies
    Like

    47

  • Suzanne Somers, Joyce Dewitt Bury Rivalry, Stage 'Three's Company' Reunion
    Like

    755

  • Miranda Lambert Makes Emotional Return to On Fire Tour
    Like

    9

  • The Most Controversial Super Bowl Commercials
    Like

    160

  • Paris Jackson Boyfriend: MJ's Daughter Dating a Rapper?
    Like

    32

  • Evangelical Christian Group Calls For Starbucks Boycott
    Like

    7K

  • Supreme Court Leaves Clues How It Will Decide Health Reform
    Like

    499

  • Koch Brothers, Allies Pledge $100 Million At Private Meeting To Beat Obama
    Like

    15K

  • WATCH: Anchorwoman Has Inevitable Sausage Story Slip-Up
    Like

    3K

  • PHOTOS: The Week's Worst And Wildest Weather
    Like

    68

  • Ann Coulter's Revealing Private Talk With Mitt Romney
    Like

    212

  • AGAIN? Second Teacher Arrested After Accusations Surface
    Like

    358

  • Busty Woman Blames DUI Bust On Her Boobs
    Like

    852

  • 11 Amazing/Disgusting Snack Stadiums
    Like

    1K

  • In The Midst Of Latino Population Growth, Lawmaker Proposes Holiday For White People. No Joke.
    Like

    2K

Also on AOL

Quick Links

  • Slipknot Masks
  • Saddest Songs
  • Funny Music Videos
  • SXSW 2011

Also on AOL Music

  • Concert Tickets
  • Grammys 2012
  • Music Videos
  • New Music Releases

Blogs on AOL

  • Country Music
  • Hip Hop Music
  • Metal Music
  • Pop Music News

More on AOL

  • Best Lyrics
  • Best Metal Songs
  • Break Up Songs
  • Online Radio

More on AOL

  • Christmas Music
  • Classic Rock Songs
  • Best Songs of 2010
  • SHOUTcast

Help Links

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • About Our Ads
  • Follow Spinner on Twitter
  • The Interface
  • Free MP3
  • Full CDs
  • RSS

Spinner.com © 2011 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.