• AOL
  • MAIL
    • You might also like: 
    • Music | 
    • Movies | 
    • TV | 
    • Celebrity News
    •  and More
    Sign In / Register
Spinner
  • Main
  • Spinner RPM
  • Features
    • The Hit List
    • Spinner Interview
    • Tributes & Essays
    • Music Appreciation
  • Songs
    • Free MP3 of the Day
    • Play Full Albums Free
  • Videos
    • The Interface
    • Sessions
    • Video of the Day
    • All Videos
  • Radio
    • AOL Radio
    • AOL Radio Toolbar
    • Shoutcast
  • AOL Music Sites
    • The Boot
    • The BoomBox
    • Noisecreep
    • AOL Music Blog
  • SXSW
  • Send Feedback
  • Dianna Agron Glee

    Hear New 'Glee' Songs
  • Sharon Van Etten

    Hear Sharon Van Etten's 'Tramp' for Free
  • Beyonce

    Get Beyonce News
  • Faith Hill

    Faith Hill Shares Tips for Staying in Shape
  • Ringo Starr

    Read Ringo Starr Interview
  • Janet Jackson

    Super Bowl Halftime Bloopers
  • Kellie Pickler

    Read Kellie Pickler Interview
  • Chris Brown

    Chris Brown 'Wins' Unwelcome Award

Spinner Exclusives

  • The Interface - Live Performances
  • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free
  • Spinner Radio
  • Listening Parties - New CDS for Free

Features

  • Best Songs 2011
  • Top Albums of 2011
  • Sad Songs
  • Music Geeks in Film
  • Best Opening Lyrics

All Categories

  • Monthly Mixtape(1)
  • A Day in the Life(5)
  • All About Jazz(96)
  • Awards(232)
  • Free MP3 Download of the Day(1673)
  • Around the World(205)
  • Between the Notes(36)
  • Book Club(94)
  • Celebrity Doppelganger(18)
  • Clash of the Cover Songs(49)
  • Coming Out Stories(23)
  • Concerts and Tours(6842)
  • Count Five(83)
  • Exclusive(5977)
  • Guest Blogger(133)
  • Holy Hell(1016)
  • I Fought the Law(111)
  • I Freakin' Love This Song(252)
  • In House(12)
  • Listen Up!(18)
  • Movies(424)
  • Music Appreciation(123)
  • New Music(861)
  • New Releases(614)
  • News(12267)
  • PhotoSynthesis(88)
  • Picture Book(31)
  • Politics as Usual(61)
  • Pop Culture(93)
  • Potent Quotables(776)
  • Q + A(493)
  • Quizzes & Trivia(6)
  • R.I.P.(454)
  • Road Report(61)
  • Rock Almanac(366)
  • Rock Hall(44)
  • RPM(263)
  • Spinner Says(15)
  • Spinner Interview(212)
  • Television(243)
  • The Chum Bucket(777)
  • The Hit List(1388)
  • Twisted Tales(194)
  • Video(1784)
  • Video of the Day(1225)
  • What's That Song?(134)

Ian McCulloch: 'U2 Are for Teenagers'

  • Posted on Nov 25th 2009 4:52AM by Richard Moore
  • Comments
Email This
Echo and the Bunnymen's Ian McCulloch has once again singled out U2 for a tongue-lashing, branding the Irish megastars' music as "flag-waving" and "immature."

McCulloch has regularly stated his aversion to Bono and friends and appears to love using the press to express his disdain. Last year he referred to them as "spud peelers" whose ambition was to join music's elite stars like Bob Geldof, Sting and "all them c---s who no one really likes."

This time around, while he was slightly less vitriolic, McCulloch continued to ridicule U2 for appealing only to a younger, less-mature fan base and being nothing more than a commercial enterprise. "Bands all say they want to be as big as U2, but weirdly no one ever says they're influenced by them," he told New York magazine. "That's because there's nothing there, really."

He continued, "They've got good tunes, and you can see that it works on 14-year-olds. But I can't see mature people or kids, who are looking for something, something deep -- something that you just know it's art and it's going to change your life -- caring. For U2, it's always flag-waving and 'Yippee.'"

Not that McCulloch's jealous of course. Echo & the Bunnymen begin a UK tour of mid-sized theatres in December, while U2 have recently concluded a tour of the world's biggest sports stadiums.

  • Filed under: News
  • Email This

All the AOL Music info you want to know

Dierks Bentley, 'Live on Letterman'…

The Boot

Ethan Miller, Getty Images Country takes over the city, as Dierks Bentley is…

Drake, Juno Awards 2012: Young Money MC…

The Boombox

Getty Images After hosting the Juno Awards last year -- the Canadian…

Grammy Awards: Hip-Hop and R&B Albums…

The Boombox

Amazon.com The Best Rap Album category was born in 1996, during the…

See all AOL Music »

Add a Comment

Sign in »
*0 / 3000 Character Maximum
85

103 Comments

Filter by:
Ian

Ye would just hate to go to a U2 concert. What a bunch of wankers. 'Bono met the Pope'. So fucking what! Are they really saying that no-one can criticise their precious little rock stars, who send them home bent on changing the world. Get yer lighters out, boys and girls, it's 'With or Without You' again.

April 03 2010 at 4:21 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
ad

I love both bands.
But they play in a different league.
U2 is mainstream, most of Echo isnt.
Comparing them is pointless.

February 07 2010 at 11:01 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Scotty

Ian is over and he knows it ! he's looking for publicity. So all you U2 haters keep playing your 80s cd's of echo and getting high on remembering your parachute pants and member only jackets and how it was.I just saw EATB on the charts list "NOT" !!! Bono-Edge-Larry- Adam keep rocking and making Music for all ages,keep up the great work Brian,Steve and Daniel this fan of all music here , loves the diversity since 83 at Stony Brook U when I saw the four Irishmen start and conquer the music world!!!!

January 08 2010 at 10:02 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
kim

Bono doesn't need Ian McCulloch to like him...he likes himself enough for everyone! Bono is the most self-important, pompous, narcissitc, portentuous blow hard i have ever seen.
Ian feels his own importance as well, but musically, Echo and the Bunnymen have been more influential than U2..hell, U2 was once an opening act for the Bunnymen. U2 had better management, thusly they are better known. However---there is not a better album out there than the Bunnymen's Heaven Up Here, unless it's the Bunnymen's Ocean Rain. Their latest effort, The Fountain, failed to impress me, but I bought it and am flying across the Atlantic next week to see them in concert and I didn't even bother to buy tickets to see U2 when there were here in the US...so that tells you something of how the Bunnymen stack up against U2 in my book.

December 12 2009 at 11:52 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
ineedanapp

Ian needs to quit smoking...especially during shows. His live vocals SUCK.

December 01 2009 at 4:23 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Mark J

Why's Ian dissing U2 when HIS band name
has the word 'BUNNY' in it!!?!

November 30 2009 at 9:31 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
nechamah

Hmm-- I guess it is true; I've been a teen, possibly immature, too, for over 30 years now and I love u2. And I second tub's comment and I'll help.

November 30 2009 at 2:16 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
TommyTrojan

echo and the bunnymen - put out 2nd rate music and lyrics that no one cares to listen to and then call other people's music purile - what an arse - you know where you can find musicians 'influenced' by echo and the bunnymen; working at Euro Disney, in Fantasy Land, because they don't exist ....

November 30 2009 at 2:08 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
LuAnn

Speak for yourself Ian ! I am soon to be 55 years old and have recognised U-2 as a global success from day one. Not only do they rock to their their own unique sound, but they utilize their extreme talent to touch the world with great humanitarian efforts. God bless the boys! I am, have always been, and certainly will always remain, a rock solid U-2 affectionado! My love goes out to the boys!

November 30 2009 at 2:06 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
GRAYDOG


U2 ARE WITHOUT DOUBT THE MOST FINANCIALLY SUCCESSFULL BAND WITHOUT A SHRED OF TALENT OR CREATIVITY SINCE THE BEACH BOYS. BONO IS A POMPASS ASS, AND WORLD CLASS POSER. I CARE NOT FOR POLITICS OR WHO'S GOT AIDS, OR STARVING IN SOME THIRD WORLD SHIT HOLE.U2 FANS HAVE TO BE MENTAL PYGMIES OR DEAF.WHAT GIVES THEM THE RIGHT COME TO THE USA, AND PREACH ABOUT SAVING THE WORLD ? MOST OF THESE COUNTRIES JUST NEED TO GET UP OFF THERE ASS, AND MAYBE TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR THEIR OWN LIVES AND FUTURES. GET OFF YOUR SOAP BOX BONO, NOBODY GIVES A RAT'S ASS WHAT YOU CARE ABOUT.

November 30 2009 at 2:01 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Reply
Load more comments

Follow Us

  • Newsletter
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS

Sign Up for Spinner's Newsletter! Get free MP3s, play a selection of each week's new albums free, read features, win sweet music swag and more!




  • Contact Us
  • Send News Tips
  • Advertise with Us

SIGN UP FOR SPINNER'S NEWSLETTER

  • Get free MP3s, play a selection of each week's new albums free, read features, win sweet music swag and more!

  • Sign Up!

AOL Radio

Listen to Slacker AOL Radio Now
play arrow
Top Indie - Today's best indie rock and pop
play arrow
Indie Rock Mix - A mix of new and old indie rock
play arrow
New Indie First - The latest in indie music
Online Radio Guide

Listen to Full CDs

  • Paul McCartney, 'Kisses on the Bottom'
  • Sharon Van Etten, 'Tramp'
  • AIR, 'Le Voyage Dans La Lune'
  • Bahamas, 'Barchords'
  • Band of Skulls, 'Sweet Sour'
  • Play More Albums Free

Most Popular

  • Madonna Super Bowl Halftime Show: Romans, Cheerleaders and MIA's Middle Finger
    Like

    202

  • Katy Perry Divorce: With No Prenup How Much Will Russell Walk Away With?
    Like

    10

  • Randy Travis Apologizes for Public Intoxication
    Like

    245

  • M.I.A., Fiance Benjamin Bronfman Split, Singer Rarely Sees Son -- Report
    Like

    53

  • Randy Travis Arrested in Texas
    Like

    239

  • The Best Colleges For The Socially Awkward Student
    Like

    3K

  • Alori Joh Dead: Singer and Kendrick Lamar Affiliate Dies at 25
    Like

    74

  • Josh Powell's Last Words: 'I Am Not Able To Go On Anymore': Report
    Like

    956

  • Puddle of Mudd Singer Arrested in January for Drug Possession
    Like

    139

  • 1 Can Of Paint, 25 Different Ways
    Like

    129

  • Cee Lo's Super Bowl Strip Club Outing: Singer Reportedly Drops $10K
    Like

    45

  • Powell 911 Call Released: Cops Declare Investigation Of Missing Mom A Murder Case
    Like

    321

  • Thudda Boy Dead: Rapper Brondon McDaniel Dies From Gunshot Wound
    Like

    40

  • WATCH: Gisele Curses Drops By Patriots Receivers
    Like

    1K

  • Miranda Lambert Makes Emotional Return to On Fire Tour
    Like

    16

  • American Heart Month: 17 Celebrities Who Faced Heart Problems
    Like

    18

  • The Worst Super Bowl Commercials Of 2012
    Like

    110

  • PHOTOS: Anti-Gay Protesters Getting Pwned
    Like

    2K

  • Boys Blown Up By Dad Allegedly Talked About Mom's Disappearance
    Like

    572

  • PHOTOS: Rihanna Shows Off Everything In Sheer Top
    Like

    82

  • Laura Linney's Colorful Frocks
    Like

    9

  • PHOTO: Miley Cyrus Wears Racy Garters
    Like

    60

  • PHOTOS: Gisele Comforts Tom Brady
    Like

    221

  • Is Social Media Causing The Mystery Illness?
    Like

    1K

  • PHOTOS: Massive Whale Shark Reeled Into Harbor
    Like

    1K

  • Powell Boys Suffered 'Chop Injuries' Before Explosion
    Like

    457

  • The Best And Worst Burgers
    Like

    115

  • WATCH: Father Of Missing Alaska Barista Increases Reward
    Like

    441

  • Prop 8, California's Same-Sex Marriage Ban, Declared Unconstitutional
    Like

    16K

  • Missing Alaska Barista Had Filed Restraining Order Against Man
    Like

    225

  • Post 50 Celebrity Dream Homes on the Market (PHOTOS)
    Like

    15

  • VOTE: The Best Super Bowl Ad
    Like

    638

  • Dead Man Found In Foreclosed Home Four Years Later
    Like

    1K

Also on AOL

Quick Links

  • Slipknot Masks
  • Saddest Songs
  • Funny Music Videos
  • SXSW 2011

Also on AOL Music

  • Concert Tickets
  • Grammys 2012
  • Music Videos
  • New Music Releases

Blogs on AOL

  • Country Music
  • Hip Hop Music
  • Metal Music
  • Pop Music News

More on AOL

  • Best Lyrics
  • Best Metal Songs
  • Break Up Songs
  • Online Radio

More on AOL

  • Christmas Music
  • Classic Rock Songs
  • Best Songs of 2010
  • SHOUTcast

Help Links

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • About Our Ads
  • Follow Spinner on Twitter
  • The Interface
  • Free MP3
  • Full CDs
  • RSS

Spinner.com © 2011 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved.