Billy Corgan Calls Smashing Pumpkins Split a 'Mistake'
- Posted on Dec 10th 2009 9:00AM by Benjy Eisen
- Comments (37)
Billy Corgan has always done things a little bit differently. As the leader of Smashing Pumpkins, he was a vanguard for the alternative rock movement in the 1990s. Even as the notion of "alternative" shape-shifts into "indie," Corgan has, indeed remained independent to the core. He was one of the first artists to demonstrate that you could be signed to a major label and still keep not only your integrity but also control of your art -- even when his own band was spiraling out of control, the subject of much public drama and perhaps even some sensationalism.Now, with 19-year-old Mike Byrne on the skins, Corgan is the last man standing from the original group. Sitting in the Spinner offices, he offers us a glimpse at Smashing Pumpkins 3.0, coinciding with the announcement that the band plans to roll out 44 songs, one at a time, over the next few years for free. The tracks will form the basis for the new Smashing Pumpkins album, 'Teargarden by Kaleidyscope,' which will eventually be released as 11 four-song EPs.
All this from a band that released an entire album for free ('Machina II') back in 2000, before it became hip to do so. If history is any indication, maybe every band will start releasing massive amounts of four-song EPs. Then again, that could end up just being a Smashing Pumpkins thing.
Why are you releasing the 44 songs of 'Teargarden by Kaleidyscope' for free?
I've never been comfortable with the idea that you work for a couple of years just to come up with a pile of 12 songs and that becomes the album. What I like about the idea of recording the songs one at a time is I'm always in the moment with the song. I'm hoping it will raise the quality of the songs that I release so that every song is important to me. Hopefully the audience will feel that way too.
It's going to take a while for the record business to find its new bearings. In the meantime, it keeps acting like it's the old record business, which I think really works against the artistic aspect of putting out music. I thought I would walk around all of that, make the songs available for free and I figured out a way that I could feel invested. I figure it's going to take three years and I'm always putting out something I feel excited about, and then I'm also getting some level of feedback from the audience about what they're actually connecting with.
Releasing 'Machina II' for free seemed like a middle finger to your record label, Virgin. Was that what you intended?
I was very frustrated in 2000 when we wanted to put out 'Machina II.' We were out of our record deal and the label had absolutely no interest, even though 'Machina' had sold pretty well. They wanted nothing to do with me or us, so rather than just have all this music sit in a box somewhere, we decided just to put it out. It was a very exciting time because it was maybe an early hint at what we're in now. All artists are kind of in this immediacy where a grainy YouTube video is something that is just as important as a $500,000 video. If it connects with people, it connects. Back then it was sort of a point of revenge. Little did I know that it was a forbearance of things to come.
Do you regret breaking up Smashing Pumpkins in 2000?
Breaking up the band was a mistake because I think it broke trust with the audience. You had an audience that was very invested in that idea -- whether they were invested in the people or the idea or the songs, I don't know. Like a relationship that you break off from and then try to pick back up, it's never quite the same. It doesn't mean it can't be as good, but it has to be different. That beautiful original feeling got lost in the interim of being away. If we had said, "We just went away for seven years," it would have been similar, but somehow breaking up, there's a violence to it.
Many fans said things like, "You reformed Smashing Pumpkins but really it's just in name." Do you think that's a valid criticism?
Anything is a fair criticism. The question I would ask is, "Do I have the right to do it?" Based upon what I've seen since reforming the band, I do have the right. If I felt I didn't, I would sit here honestly and say, "Nah, I probably should've just left it alone." I've been making music with the intention of connecting with an audience for 20 years now, so at the end of the day I have to be accountable to me in that way. I can't not do what I believe in because somebody else doesn't feel the same way I do about it.
Your new drummer, Mike Byrne, is 19 years old. Are you going to let him drink backstage?
You know what's funny? I don't even know if he drinks. I've never seen him drink.
What was the drummer audition process like?
We got over 1,000 submissions. Most people sent in a little bio, maybe a picture and then a YouTube link. We had to go through all these submissions and they kind of wound down to a pile. There were people from really great bands that were interested, and so I'm looking at all these great drummers and I get to this one. My friend is loading up the YouTube clip and the kid is 19 years old. My first thought was "No way!" Press play and it's him just going off at some music store. He's not even playing a beat, he's just going off. I thought, "Wow, this kid is really something."
Then we called him down for an audition. He was probably the seventh drummer that I had seen that day. I looked at him and I thought this kid looks really young -- he looks like the little kid. He was super nervous. I had a very similar feeling the first time with him that I had the first time I played with Jimmy Chamberlin. There's just something about playing with a great drummer that just gives you a chill. The next thing you know, I'm on the phone with his parents telling them that I'm actually thinking about hiring him.
Not to cut him out of the process, but I didn't want it to be him walking into the living room going, "Mom and dad, Billy wants to hire me for the Smashing Pumpkins." I wanted them to understand that it was a legitimate thing, that he wasn't in some kind of fantasy. He's a really great person, a fantastic musician. I love his attitude. Only certain drummers can play like that at such a young age. The fact that he's playing like this at 19 makes me wonder where he's going to be at in five years.
The great thing is that he grew up listening to the Pumpkins and loves Jimmy's playing, so there's no weird thing there. For him, he completely understands what he's being asked to do because he understands where the band has come from. It feels like this was the way everything was meant to happen.
What has surprised you most about your career?
If you went back in a time machine to 1993, recording 'Siamese Dream,' somebody could say "This is what's going to happen" and I would never have believed it. I would never have believed all the bad things, I would never have believed many of the good things. If I could go back in a time machine and talk to me back then, the thing would surprise him is that at some point I was willing to walk away from being servile to success.
That's a difficult question as an artist because art really is about serving. You want to communicate but there was something about the process of making others happy that somehow was making me feel unhappy. It made me crazy, but I was good at it. It's like you're being rewarded for something that hurts you, but yet everybody is telling you it's a good thing. Then you try to pull that energy back into yourself, you try to make it more about you, and then suddenly you're not making people happy. You're making yourself happy but now that's another form of unhappiness because now you're making other people unhappy. It's taken a long time to get to a place of being OK with it all.
I don't get into the grandiose, "If only one person is touched by it ..." I want people to hear what I'm doing but I think I only go so far. It won't be at the expense of my life, my health, my sanity. If that makes me sort of just an okay artist, well then, I can live with that.
- Filed under: Exclusive, Spinner Interview
- Share & Bookmark :






Reader Comments(1 of 2)
THAGZA95at 12-10-2009
SMASHING PUMPKINS is the one of the best bands to ever exist....I grew up on Melon Collie and the infinite saddness and to this day i will listen to it and it takes me back....Billy Corgan is a genius and no matter what the outcome they will always have the cd's they released in the 90's as the original band and thats enough to make the music last forever...good luck billy
lynnebat 12-10-2009
I agree w/ you 100%. There isn't many people I admire as much as Billy Corgan. He is a genius ;)
parplexat 12-10-2009
Sorry, I had to just copy what you said. I couldnt have said it any better myself. SP was the first concert I went too and I will never forget it.
SMASHING PUMPKINS is the one of the best bands to ever exist....I grew up on Melon Collie and the infinite saddness and to this day i will listen to it and it takes me back....Billy Corgan is a genius and no matter what the outcome they will always have the cd's they released in the 90's as the original band and thats enough to make the music last forever...good luck billy
Rockinat 12-10-2009
when its over leave it there
in the dust
there is no tomorrow
whats done is done..Just
sean kellyat 12-10-2009
what a great band!
Cheers,
Sean kelly of the samples
Matt Peltzat 12-10-2009
Speaking of great bands, how about the greatest band you have never heard of... The Samples.
dcinazat 12-21-2009
Sean, I like the smaples too- but SP will forever hold a VERY special place in my heart.
PS I have wanted to marry Billy since I was 17 and am now 35 and nothing has changed too. Too funny Marissa
scorpking666at 12-10-2009
Amazing, do not get me wrong, I too live in the post george bush era(left uncapitalized on purpose) but to hate on someone who just because you did not appreciate his sound and are jealous that he could wipe his butt with the money you have, is ridiculous, i appreciate all forms of music and hate when anyone blasts anyone who has the guts to put their heart on a plate and rip them, remember Billy Corgan wasnt born with a silver spoon is his mouth, he made himself with his band a success,how dare you try to tear a man down...rot in your nonexistence...
Ari of Lightat 12-10-2009
People in Chicago love and respect Billy no matter what. He could be solo, with the Pumpkins, or a new band. Regret? Mistake? I am not sure I felt that from the interview. We can always look back at past decisions, and wonder what would have happened "if." Some how I don't think Billy would have the serenity that he seems to have now if he made other decisions.
Mat 12-11-2009
An okay artist...yeah,that's about where I would put Smashing Pumpkins."Chereb Rock" will stand as an ALL-TIME classic,but most of their other hits go down as mediocre background noise to Pearl Jam and Alice in Chains and 311. Many artists of the 90s were underrated,the Pumpkins were OVERrated,Billy should be glad that someone still wants to interview him.
jst4gpat 12-10-2009
Funny how the timing of Smashing Pumpkins reforming and Jessica Simpson supposedly hooking up coincide. She's probably looking for a new "singing" gig. Don't do it Billy....
Mindyat 12-10-2009
Of course he regrets it-his career has been in the crapper ever since!
cherubrockat 12-10-2009
Thanks for the music Billy! Smashing Pumpkins was the first real band I ever loved and they still hold a special place that music has been unable to touch since. It's wonderful and refreshing to hear of an artist with as much talent and originality deciding to sidestep the whole industry and share their music with the fans for free simply because they want to share the music. Thank you!
steveat 12-10-2009
if you never bought his music and change the channel when his songs are on the radio, why on earth would you read this and then take the time to post a comment???
mandarrae89at 12-10-2009
I respect Smashing Pumpkins as a band. The music is amazing. However, I am not a huge fan of Billy's voice. It turns me off of them completely. Everyone has their own opinions...
JBat 12-10-2009
While I have enjoyed many of the Pumpkins' songs since, I believe that their best album, without a doubt, was their debut - Gish - released way back in 1991. I remember seeing that album at the music store (when there was no 'iTunes' and music stores were more widespread) and thinking, "Hmmm...that's an odd name and the cover looks interesting." Bought it, gave it a listen and was blown away. Their sound managed to both fit into the early 90s sound (possibly, overall, the greatest period in all of rock music with bands like The Red Hot Chili Peppers, Soundgarden, Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, Pearl Jam, Screaming Trees, Pantera, White Zombie AND a Metallica that hadn't yet completely sold out) while doing their own thing at the same time. A few months later I saw their video for "I Am One" on MTV (yes, believe it or not, MTV used to play music videos) and was even more impressed - the video was just plain different. Corgan has always been a little 'odd' but I have enjoyed his music (I even liked the stuff he did with Zwan.)
helloat 12-10-2009
I am of the *older* generation and I LOVED (and still love) Smashing Pumpkins! Nothing can replace the original band.
Davidat 12-10-2009
I liked "Siamese Dream" better than "Mellon Collie..." Mellon Collie was too long, too many "filler" songs it reminded me of Prog-Rock from the 1970's. Boring! JMO.
Davidat 12-10-2009
Back in 1991 I believe it was me and a friend went to see Red Hot Chili Peppers in Houston, TX at an old dump music venue called The Unicorn Ballroom. Two unknown bands opened up for them, Pearl Jam and Smashing Pumpkins! All these bands and I think the ticket was 20 bucks or something ridiculously cheap. I really only watched RHCP's though did not know the other bands or their music was busy drinking and smoking during their sets!!
Erickat 12-11-2009
Melanchollie was the first CD I ever owned. It was what made me want to play music for the first time. I grew up in a VERY religious family, and I remember hiding my SP CD's and sneaking them out at night and listening to them on my headphones all night!