Metallica's James Hetfield recently stated that the band was in the final process…
Politician Proposes $25 Fine for Singers Who Mess With National Anthem
- Posted on Jan 5th 2012 11:33AM by Cameron Matthews
KMazur, WireImage
Besides creating YouTube fodder, all these reworkings have really ticked off one patriot in particular: Indiana state senator Vaneta Becker. How angry is she, you ask? Enough that she's proposing a bill to fine performers who mess with the national anthem.
"Sometimes it's just done in a joking manner, but I don't think the national anthem is something we ought to be joking around with," Becker told the Star Press, referring to a case where the lyrics were changed in a school's parody version. The politician is proposing a $25 fine for anyone who intentionally changes the words or strays from the original melody. On top of that, the law would be strictly enforced in schools, which would be required to record every performance -- for two years!
"I don't think it would be very difficult for schools," she said. "You could record it on a lot of cellphones or like a small recording device [or] a CD."
Even though Becker is calling on state resources to fix this national crisis, she isn't out to fine singers who are melodically challenged or forget the words (ahem, Christina Aguilera). In that case, we're guessing she's not a fan of Jimi Hendrix's classic ripping of the banner at Woodstock.
Check out our list of the worst 'Star-Spangled Banner' performances below and let us know what you think of the proposed bill.
- Filed under: News, Politics as Usual
Around The Web:
Indiana State Senator Vaneta Becker Proposes Fines for Editing ...
Lawmaker: National Anthem Singing Should Be Regulated - Indiana ...
Indiana bill would outlaw singing national anthem 'inappropriately ...
US Politics | AMERICAblog News: Indiana bill to fine 'inappropriate ...
Lucianne.com News Forum - Thread
Columbus Artfest Fine Art Festival
Sly In The Morning: $25 fine for National Anthem Naughtyness
Add a Comment
Oh my God, can we get SERIOUS here??? It's MUSIC! It's EXPRESSION! It's an old English DRINKING SONG!
If you're truly offended by any variation in it's delivery, why not pass a law that this tired Relic MUST be RECITED ONLY, and NEVER SUNG? And not only recited, but spoken ONLY IN A SPECIFICALLY MIDWESTERN ACCENT... not the "uncouth" East Coast version, the "lazy" Southern Drawl, the suspiciously Canadian-tinged clipped Northern variation, or the highly suspicious West Coast-y Valley Girl/Surfer Dude option?
Better yet, played only as an ultimately predictable, safely pre-recorded robotic "voice", without emotion or any other sign of human involvement. A little like Mitt Romney's campaign speeches.
Do you ever just shut up and stop complaining about everything all over the internet? You, who has no clue what truth is, get a life! Better yet, get a job and get off the internet!
January 18 2012 at 12:12 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyWow, its amazing how small minds are afraid of anything or any opinion they dont like or dont even understand.
Listen to authority and do as youre told, dont question anything and believe everything, I know your type.
Thoughs, ideas and even simple things like discussion scare you.
Most likely because you dont comprehend what they are.
Sit in front of the boob tube and consume at the trough.
Reading jefgat, I see someone who is cultured and whose knowledge is vast and his jibe at Romney was excellent.
I read your words and I see a dumb hick who can barely put words together and express a thought.
Really you shouldnt be having any kidn of battle of wits when you are so clearly underarmed.
actually buying a house for these stars is like a regular joe/jane buying a hamburger, so 25 bucks is less than a penny, they should withhold pay or fine the something theyll remember
January 06 2012 at 12:18 PM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down ReplyMaybe these singers need to get a lesson on the National Anthem from Lori Morgan. I had the privilege of hearing her sing it at a NASCAR Winston Cup Race at the Rockingham, NC race track back in the early 2000's. It was without a doubt the best rendition that I have ever heard. With no music, Miss Morgan belted our song out flawlessly! It still makes me feel very fortunate to have been there just remembering how well it was performed.
January 06 2012 at 11:32 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyThey've been messing with the Bible for thousands of years and yet it survives.
January 06 2012 at 10:01 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyIs $25.00 enough for the BIG money makers of our country to pay for messing up the National Anthem? Really these singer? I question the singer part yuck! They live in a country where you can earn that kind of money and they want to howl like a dog and change the words and act so disrepectful. Who picks these people? Oh yeah probably the people who don't care they are just looking for names that draw the crowds. Let's see our men and women instead of playing on the fields are risking their lives on a different like of field keep our country safe and we let individuals make fun of county and our song and our flag. This is SAD!!! Come on America why do you honor these people??? I don't get it!!!
January 06 2012 at 7:04 AM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down Reply$25 fine? Are you kidding me? That's like giving performers a 5 cent fine.
How about a $25,000 fine, AND they don't get paid for the performance.
Too many Americans paid the ultimate price to defend this country. In my opinion, freedom of speech does not apply here. This anthem is too sacred to our country, and should be performed in that manner. Shame on all you "professional performers", for thinking that you are too "hip" to perform properly. America made you famous...You owe America!
bout time... let the local sing its. You can see that the professional (so called) singiner are so into themselves they the focus is on them not the anthem
January 06 2012 at 6:23 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down ReplyYA WANNA MAKE A DIFFERENCE ? NEXT TIME YOUR AT A SPORTING EVENT AND ONE OF THESE LAZY DRUG ADDICTED IDIOTS TORTURE THE NATIONAL ANTHEM BOO THE CRAP OUT OF THEM !!!! FOR THE ENTIRE TIME THEY SING IT !!!! ON NATIONAL TV , IF THEY HAVE ANY BRAINS AT ALL THEY WILL HEAR YOU
January 06 2012 at 6:14 AM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down ReplyThat'll be effective. Booing during the National Anthem. That'll get your point across. Good call.
January 07 2012 at 1:10 PM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replythe jimi hendrix rendition of the star spangled banner at the woodstock festival totally KICKED ASS! AWESOME!
January 06 2012 at 6:04 AM Report abuse Permalink rate up rate down Replyare you kidding me!!! $25? THAT is more of an insult than throwing a few lame lyrics in a song...big stars with money to burn like steven tyler and christina aguilera will LOL, and sing on! ...come on senator becker, get out of that comfy office chair of yours and do some "real" work for the taxpayers in your state!
January 06 2012 at 5:59 AM Report abuse Permalink +1 rate up rate down Reply











1103 Comments